Devin Review iter #3 found 3 new real bugs after iter #2's fixes landed.
🔴 RBAC check at app/api/query.py:362 used `row["name"]` against
`accessible_set`, but `accessible_set` is keyed by registry IDs
(`get_accessible_tables` returns `resource_grants.resource_id` —
table IDs, not display names). Confirmed by `_table_blocks` projection
at `app/resource_types.py:157-158`. When `id != name` (e.g.
`id="bq.finance.ue", name="ue"`), non-admin users with valid grants
got 403 `bq_path_access_denied`. Switch to `row["id"]`.
🚩 Bare-name pass at app/api/query.py:332 had the same name-vs-id
mismatch (different impact): legitimate accessible rows were skipped
from `dry_run_set`, so the cost guardrail under-counted scan bytes
for non-admin users. Could let an over-cap query through and
under-bill quota. Switch to `row_id` comparison.
🟡 `placeholder_from` for billing_project was dead code.
`_BQ_OPTIONAL_FIELD_DEFAULTS["billing_project"] = ""` seeded an empty
string into every GET payload via `_ensure_bq_optional_fields`. JS
`isUnset = (value === undefined)` evaluated False, so the
`(defaults to <project>)` placeholder NEVER rendered. Drop the seed —
field stays in `known_fields` (UI sees it) but routes through the
unset rendering path on GET, where placeholder_from fires.
Tests: test_get_surfaces_bq_fields_even_when_unset assertion flipped
from "billing_project IS present" to "billing_project NOT auto-seeded"
to lock in the new shape. 67 affected tests pass.
E2E test on dev VM revealed: spec said "configurable via /admin/server-config"
for the cost guardrail cap, but the underlying read path was
`api.query.bq_max_scan_bytes` and `api` is NOT in `_EDITABLE_SECTIONS`. POST
to /admin/server-config rejected `{"sections":{"api":...}}` as "unknown
section(s): api" — the cap was only adjustable via direct YAML edit.
Move to `data_source.bigquery.bq_max_scan_bytes`:
- `_default_remote_query_cap_bytes()` reads from the new path.
- Add to `_OPTIONAL_FIELDS["data_source"]["bigquery"]["fields"]` with the
same shape as `max_bytes_per_materialize` (kind=int, default 5 GiB, hint).
- Add to `_BQ_OPTIONAL_FIELD_DEFAULTS` so it surfaces in the GET payload
even when YAML omits it.
Convention now mirrors `max_bytes_per_materialize` — both BQ cost
guardrails live under `data_source.bigquery`, both editable in the UI.
Closes the operator-side half of the reporter's loop. The CLI fix in
the previous commit makes USER_PROJECT_DENIED errors readable to
analysts; this commit lets admins verify reachability proactively
from /admin/server-config without waiting for analyst reports.
New endpoint POST /api/admin/bigquery/test-connection
(app/api/admin_bigquery_test.py, ~110 LOC):
- Depends(require_admin); registered in app/main.py.
- Builds BqAccess via existing get_bq_access(), runs `SELECT 1 AS ok`
with a 10s polling timeout.
- 200 with {ok, billing_project, data_project, elapsed_ms} on success.
- 400 for `BqAccessError(not_configured)` (operator config issue).
- 502 for any other typed BqAccessError or unknown upstream exception.
- 504 for concurrent.futures.TimeoutError; best-effort cancel_job
invoked (BQ-side cancel may still run; documented caveat).
Server-config placeholder (app/api/admin.py + admin_server_config.html):
- `data_source.bigquery.billing_project` field-spec gains
`placeholder_from: ["data_source", "bigquery", "project"]`.
- renderLeafInput's text branch reads `opts.spec.placeholder_from`,
walks the loaded `original` config dict, injects
`placeholder="(defaults to <project>)"` into the input HTML at
construction time. Admin sees the access.py:339-340 fallback rule
visible directly in the UI without reading source.
UI button:
- "Test BigQuery connection" button next to data_source's Save button.
- onTestBigQuery() POSTs to the endpoint, renders structured result
inline (green check + elapsed_ms on success; red kind + hint on
failure).
Tests: 6 endpoint cases + 1 placeholder payload test = 7 GREEN. 62
total across the affected admin server-config test files.
Now that VIEW/MATERIALIZED_VIEW always wrap via bigquery_query() (the
prior `legacy_wrap_views=True` branch behavior, made unconditional in
the previous commit), the toggle has no semantic meaning and is removed
across the codebase.
Production code:
- app/api/admin.py: drop the field from _OPTIONAL_FIELDS["data_source"]
["bigquery"]["fields"] and from _BQ_OPTIONAL_FIELD_DEFAULTS, plus the
comment block above the defaults dict.
- config/instance.yaml.example: drop the example snippet.
- src/orchestrator.py: update the inner-objects skip-branch comment to
reflect the new BQ behavior (the skip itself stays — keboola
use_extension=False still inserts _meta rows without inner views).
- app/web/templates/admin_tables.html: rewrite operator copy in the
register and edit forms to reflect always-wrap.
Tests:
- tests/test_admin_server_config.py (TestServerConfigBigQueryFields):
flip assertions from "field IS present" to "field NOT present" on
legacy_wrap_views. Drop the test_post_persists_legacy_wrap_views test
since the field no longer exists.
- tests/test_admin_server_config_known_fields.py: same flip on the
known-fields registry assertion.
- tests/test_bigquery_extractor.py: drop the obsolete
test_view_entity_does_not_create_master_view_by_default (asserted the
bug we fixed) and test_legacy_wrap_views_toggle_restores_old_behavior
(toggle no longer meaningful). Update remaining test docstrings.
Operators with `legacy_wrap_views: true` set in their overlay get the
new (equivalent) behavior automatically — the unrecognized key is
silently ignored by the YAML loader. Operators with `false` get the
issue-#160 fix as a behavior change, not a regression.
Spec gate updated: production code grep gate
grep -rn 'legacy_wrap_views' connectors app src config cli
must return zero. tests/ excluded — historical "removed in #160"
breadcrumbs and `assert "X" not in fields` regression guards retained
as anti-regression signals.
The strict source_type-availability validator from the prior commit
broke ~12 existing tests that register tables on the default test
instance (where `data_source.type` resolves to 'local' since no
instance.yaml is loaded).
The intent of the validator is to catch *explicit* misconfig:
`type=bigquery` instance + `source_type=keboola` payload with no
`data_source.keboola.*` block. The bootstrap workflow — admin sets up
a fresh instance and registers a few tables before pointing at a real
source — should not be gated here.
Loosen the check: when `get_data_source_type()` returns 'local' (the
fallback when no `data_source.type` is set), skip the rejection. The
explicit mismatch case still 422s because that path resolves
`configured_primary` to a real source type.
Also adds an autouse keboola_instance fixture to test_journey_sync_query.py
which exercises Keboola registrations through the full sync→query
flow — the fixture documents the test's data-source assumption rather
than relying on the bootstrap escape hatch.
E2E sub-agent finding: instance configured with `data_source.type='bigquery'`
and no `data_source.keboola.*` block. Admin POSTs `{source_type: 'keboola'}`
to /api/admin/register-table → returns 201, row lands in the registry, but
never syncs because the scheduler has no Keboola URL/token to ATTACH
against. Operator only notices the gap when `da catalog` keeps showing
nothing.
The new `_validate_source_type_configured` helper runs immediately after
the id/view-name collision checks in `register_table`. A source_type is
considered configured when:
- it matches `get_data_source_type()` (the instance's primary), OR
- a non-empty `data_source.<source_type>` block exists in the effective
`instance.yaml` (multi-source instance), OR
- it's in `_SOURCE_TYPES_INDEPENDENT_OF_DATA_SOURCE` (Jira / local — both
get data through paths that don't involve `data_source.*`).
Returns 422 with a message that names the configured primary source and
points at `/admin/server-config` for enabling a secondary one. None /
empty source_type is still tolerated for backward compat with legacy CLI
scripts that don't set the field — the route resolves it later.
5 new tests cover: keboola-on-bq rejected, bq-on-keboola rejected,
matching source_type still works, jira allowed regardless, omitted
source_type passes through.
Existing tests that registered Keboola rows on the unconfigured default
test instance now opt into a `keboola_instance` fixture to satisfy the
new validator (tests/test_admin_bq_register.py + .keboola_materialized
+ .unregister_cleanup; the multi-source PUT test in test_admin_bq_register
adds a `keboola` block to its synthetic config).
Pre-existing test_missing_project_returns_error failure in
TestRebuildFromRegistry is unrelated (config-cache leakage from a
previous test in the same class) — confirmed pre-existing on the prior
commit via `git stash` reproduction.
E2E sub-agent finding: register a materialized BQ row → sync to materialize
the parquet at `/data/extracts/bigquery/data/<id>.parquet` → DELETE the
registry row. The DB row goes away but:
- the parquet file stays on disk forever, AND
- the sync_state row stays, so `/api/sync/manifest` keeps advertising the
dropped table to `da sync`, AND
- the orchestrator's next rebuild can resurrect a master view by picking
up the leftover parquet.
Two-part fix in `unregister_table`:
1. For materialized rows on bigquery/keboola, remove
`${DATA_DIR}/extracts/<source_type>/data/<name>.parquet` (and any stale
`<name>.parquet.tmp` from a crashed prior materialize). Filename is
keyed on `table_registry.name` to match sync_state bookkeeping.
File-removal errors are logged but don't fail the DELETE — the registry
row is already gone, and an orphan parquet won't get a master view at
next rebuild because the orchestrator's _meta-driven scan never picks
up bare parquet files.
2. Always clear `sync_state` + `sync_history` rows for the dropped table_id
so the manifest stops advertising the table — applies to all source
types and modes, not just materialized, since any synced row had a
sync_state entry.
Orchestrator-side defensive guard (Finding 2b) is a no-op in the current
implementation: `_attach_and_create_views` only creates master views from
`_meta` rows in each connector's `extract.duckdb`, so a parquet without a
matching `_meta` entry is already invisible to the rebuild. The new
test `test_orchestrator_skips_orphan_parquet_in_extracts` is kept as a
regression guard for that contract.
5 tests cover: BQ + Keboola materialized DELETE removes parquet, remote
DELETE doesn't error trying to remove a non-existent file, sync_state
cleared on DELETE, orchestrator orphan-skip invariant.
E2E testing showed admin POSTs of materialized BQ rows whose source_query
uses BigQuery-native backtick identifiers (`prj.ds.t`) silently no-op'd at
the next sync tick — the materialize path runs the SQL through the DuckDB
BQ extension's COPY which uses DuckDB's parser; backticks aren't recognized
and the query either parse-errors or matches zero rows. No parquet lands at
the canonical path and no error reaches an operator-visible surface.
Two-part fix:
1. RegisterTableRequest's _check_mode_query_coherence model_validator now
rejects any source_query containing a backtick with a 422 + actionable
message pointing at the DuckDB equivalent (bq."dataset"."table"). Same
check is applied in update_table on the merged record so PATCHes that
flip a stored source_query to backtick form are also caught. Covers BQ
AND Keboola materialized rows since both connectors funnel source_query
through DuckDB's COPY.
2. _run_materialized_pass now persists per-row failures via the new
SyncStateRepository.set_error / clear_error methods (existing
sync_state.error / status columns — no schema migration). GET
/api/admin/registry enriches each row with `last_sync_error` from a
single batched SELECT against sync_state, so the admin UI / da admin
status can show "this table failed last sync because: X" instead of
operators having to trawl scheduler logs. Recovered rows have the
error cleared automatically — update_sync's success path resets
status='ok' / error=NULL on the upsert.
The materialized-path test fixture's _materialized_payload helper is
updated to use DuckDB-flavor SQL (the prior backtick example pre-dated the
fix). 6 new tests cover register/update rejection on BQ + Keboola, the
sync_state error persistence, and the registry response surface.
Devin's second review pass on commit 16938ae7 surfaced 2 more issues:
BUG_pr-review-job-58ae3148_0001 — non-BQ materialized via PUT bypasses source_query check
app/api/admin.py update_table only enforces 'query_mode=materialized
requires source_query' for source_type='bigquery' rows (via the
synthetic RegisterTableRequest at line 2129+). Non-BQ source types
(Keboola) skip the check — admin could PUT {query_mode: materialized}
on a Keboola local row without source_query, persist successfully,
then crash at the next sync tick when kb_materialize_query received
sql=None and DuckDB rejected COPY (None) TO '...'.
Fix: generic coherence guard before the BQ-specific block — for ALL
source types, query_mode='materialized' requires non-empty source_query
in the merged record. Returns 422 with a hint about reverting via
query_mode='local'/'remote'.
ANALYSIS_pr-review-job-642ff90f_0007 — diagnose returns 'ok' on BQ resolution failure
app/api/health.py:_check_bq_billing_project caught get_bq_access()
exceptions and returned status='ok' with a 'could not resolve' detail.
Automated alerting keyed on status != 'ok' would silently miss missing
google-cloud-bigquery, auth failures, or malformed config. Fix: return
status='unknown' on resolution failure — surfaces it on operator
dashboards without promoting the overall health to 'degraded' (which
'warning' does, intentionally for the billing==project case).
Tests:
- test_update_keboola_to_materialized_without_source_query_rejected:
PUT {query_mode: materialized} on a Keboola local row returns 422
with 'source_query' in the detail
- test_diagnose_returns_unknown_status_when_bq_resolution_fails:
when get_bq_access raises, the bq_config service entry surfaces
status='unknown' (not 'ok')
Full sweep: 2507 passed, 25 skipped, 0 failed (+2 from previous sweep
because of the 2 new regression tests; 8 pre-existing internal_roles
schema-migration failures still ignored per task brief).
Issue #108 Milestone 1. Adds BigQuery table registration via /admin/tables UI and `da admin register-table` CLI without hand-editing table_registry. POST /api/admin/register-table/precheck for round-trip validation. --dry-run flag on CLI. Audit-log entries on register/update/unregister. PUT /api/admin/registry/{id} now preserves registered_at (closes#130).
Replaces the BigQuery wrap-view pattern with a discovery + scoped-fetch toolkit driven by the analyst's Claude session. Adds /api/v2/{catalog,schema,sample,scan,scan/estimate}, da catalog/schema/describe/fetch/snapshot/disk-info CLI commands, sqlglot-backed WHERE validator, process-local quota tracker, agent rails skill (cli/skills/agnes-data-querying.md). BREAKING: BQ wrap views off by default — set data_source.bigquery.legacy_wrap_views=true for one cycle. Backward-compat field_validator on primary_key. Catalog cache now matches documented 300s TTL with RBAC fresh per request. Cuts release v0.14.0.
Adds /admin/server-config UI for editing instance.yaml from the web. Hardening: SSRF gate on data_source URLs, narrow-overlay write strategy, atomic writes, audit log with secret masking on shape changes, threading lock on read-modify-write, corrupt-overlay refusal on write side + louder log on read side, modal Promise resolution on backdrop dismiss, sentinel scrub on save (defense-in-depth client+server). Bundles Windows PowerShell wrapper from #80. Cuts release v0.13.0.
* fix(security+ops): #82#85#87 — auth hardening, API validation, deploy posture
Security and operational hardening across three issue groups:
- M23: docker-compose.override.yml → docker-compose.dev.yml (BREAKING, prod foot-gun)
- C13: Container runs as non-root user 'agnes' (USER directive in Dockerfile)
- M21: Docker resource limits (mem_limit, cpus) on app + scheduler
- M22: Caddyfile security headers (X-Frame-Options, X-Content-Type-Options, Referrer-Policy, -Server)
- M17: /api/health split into minimal (unauth) + /api/health/detailed (auth) (BREAKING)
- M26: release.yml restricts build-and-push to main + workflow_dispatch; paths-ignore for docs
- C2: table_id traversal validation on /api/data/{table_id}/download
- M4: Upload streaming (chunk-read + temp file) instead of full-buffer; /local-md hashed filename
- C5: reset_token removed from POST /api/users/{id}/reset-password response
- C8: Startup WARNING when no user has password_hash (bootstrap window visible)
- M9: Audit log on failed web form login (mirrors /auth/token endpoint)
- M10: Atomic magic-link consume via compare-and-swap (CONSUMED: marker + DuckDB conflict catch)
Also: SSRF protection on /api/admin/configure (#46), memory stats SQL aggregation (#90)
Generated with [Devin](https://cli.devin.ai/docs)
Co-Authored-By: Devin <158243242+devin-ai-integration[bot]@users.noreply.github.com>
* fix(review): SSRF 169.254.x.x + IPv6 multicast; M10 marker cleanup safety
Review fixes:
- Add 169.254.0.0/16 (link-local, cloud metadata) to SSRF regex — was
missing, allowing requests to AWS/GCP/Azure metadata endpoints
- Add ff[0-9a-f]{2}: (IPv6 multicast) to SSRF regex
- M10: wrap Step 3 (CONSUMED marker cleanup) in try-except with
warning log — prevents unhandled exception if DB write fails after
successful token consumption
- Add test for 169.254.169.254 SSRF rejection
Generated with [Devin](https://cli.devin.ai/docs)
Co-Authored-By: Devin <158243242+devin-ai-integration[bot]@users.noreply.github.com>
* fix(review): SSRF IPv6 bypass, CLI health endpoint, upload FD leak
Address Devin Review findings on PR #104:
1. SSRF IPv6 bypass: Replace hostname regex with DNS resolution +
ipaddress module checks. The old regex patterns like `fe80:` only
matched up to the first colon, missing real IPv6 addresses like
`fe80::1`, `fc00::1`, `ff02::1`. The new approach resolves the
hostname via getaddrinfo and checks each resulting IP against
ipaddress.is_private/is_loopback/is_link_local/is_reserved/is_multicast.
2. CLI commands broken: `da setup test-connection`, `da setup verify`,
`da diagnose`, `da status` all called /api/health expecting the old
format (status=="healthy", services dict). Now they call
/api/health/detailed for service-level checks (with graceful fallback
to the minimal endpoint when auth is not configured).
3. Temp file handle leak: _stream_to_temp returns an open
NamedTemporaryFile; callers now close it before shutil.move() to
prevent FD leaks until GC.
Also adds IPv6 SSRF test cases (loopback, link-local, unique-local,
multicast) with mocked DNS resolution for test environment independence.
Generated with [Devin](https://cli.devin.ai/docs)
Co-Authored-By: Devin <158243242+devin-ai-integration[bot]@users.noreply.github.com>
* fix(review): download regex blocks hyphenated IDs; document health split
Address Devin Review round-3 findings on PR #104:
1. _SAFE_IDENTIFIER regex blocked hyphenated table IDs: The download
endpoint used the strict SQL-identifier regex which does not allow
dots or hyphens, but Keboola table IDs like in.c-crm.orders
contain both. Switched to _SAFE_QUOTED_IDENTIFIER which allows dots
and hyphens while still blocking path-traversal chars (/, .., \)
and quote/control characters. Added test for hyphenated/dotted IDs.
2. Documented health endpoint split in DEPLOYMENT.md: Added Health
checks & external monitoring section explaining both endpoints
(minimal unauth /api/health vs authenticated /api/health/detailed)
and how to wire external monitoring tools to the detailed endpoint
with a PAT.
Generated with [Devin](https://cli.devin.ai/docs)
Co-Authored-By: Devin <158243242+devin-ai-integration[bot]@users.noreply.github.com>
* release(0.12.1): cut hotfix for snapshot integrity + #82/#85/#87 hardening
* fix(security): apply CAS pattern to password reset confirm (#82/M10 follow-up)
Devin review on the rebased PR flagged the asymmetry: magic-link verify
got the atomic compare-and-swap pattern in the original M10 fix, but
password reset confirm at /auth/password/reset/confirm was still using
read-validate-clear. Two concurrent POSTs with the same valid reset
token could both succeed in setting different new passwords (last-write-
wins). Lower severity than the magic-link race because the attacker
would need the reset token AND to race the legitimate user, but the
asymmetry was a polish gap.
Mirrors app/auth/providers/email.py::_consume_token CAS exactly: write
unique CONSUMED:<random> marker via UPDATE...WHERE token=old_token, then
SELECT to verify our marker won, then proceed. Only the winner clears
the marker and applies the password change.
New regression test_concurrent_reset_only_one_wins in
tests/test_password_flows.py::TestResetConfirm pins the contract: two
ThreadPoolExecutor workers + Barrier hit /reset/confirm with the same
token; exactly one gets 302 (password applied), the other gets 200 with
'Invalid or expired'. Sanity-checked against the pre-CAS code — both
POSTs got 302 (race confirmed).
---------
Co-authored-by: Devin <158243242+devin-ai-integration[bot]@users.noreply.github.com>
This squashes 13 commits from ma/staging plus a small docstring translation
into a single coherent unit. Three workstreams.
== RBAC v13 redesign ==
- Drops core.viewer/analyst/km_admin/admin hierarchy and the
internal_roles / group_mappings / user_role_grants / plugin_access tables.
- Replaced by user_group_members + resource_grants. Atomic v12→v13 backfill
wrapped in BEGIN/COMMIT; ROLLBACK leaves schema_version at 12 for retry.
- Two authorization primitives in app.auth.access:
require_admin — Admin-group god-mode
require_resource_access(rt, "{path}") — entity-scoped grants
Single DB lookup per request; no session cache; no implies BFS.
- /admin/access UI (single page) replaces /admin/role-mapping +
/admin/plugin-access. CLI `da admin group/grant *` replaces
`da admin role/mapping/grant-role/revoke-role/effective-roles`.
- ResourceType.TABLE listing-only — admins can record table grants,
runtime enforcement still flows through legacy dataset_permissions
(migration plan in docs/TODO-rbac-data-enforcement.md).
== Claude Code marketplace ==
- Aggregated /marketplace.zip + /marketplace.git/* (PAT-gated,
RBAC-filtered, content-addressed cache via dulwich).
- Admin god-mode dropped on the marketplace surface — admins curate
their own view via grants like everyone else.
- Bare-repo cache materializes per RBAC-filtered ETag; stale entries
not pruned in this iteration (disclaimed in git_backend.py docstring).
== #81#83#44 security/ops hardening ==
- #81 Group A — orchestrator ATTACH allow-listing (extension/url/alias).
- #81 Group B — Keboola extractor 3-state exit codes:
0 success / 1 total fail / 2 PARTIAL fail
Sync API logs PARTIAL FAILURE alert on exit 2. Operators with binary
alerting must teach it the new partial signal.
- #81 Group C — schema v10 view_ownership; rejects silent overwrite
of a prior connector's view name on collision.
- #81 Group D — extractor-side identifier validation.
- #83 — Jira webhook fail-closed when JIRA_WEBHOOK_SECRET unset
+ path-traversal fix.
- #44 — entire /api/scripts/* surface is admin-only (planted-script +
sandbox-bypass risk closed).
== Web UI polish + deploy fix ==
- /admin/access: live grant-count badges (no stale snapshot revert),
shared-header CSS link added to /catalog and /admin/{tables,permissions},
per-resource-type colored stripes.
- docker-compose.host-mount.yml: bind,rbind so dual-disk hosts don't
silently shadow sub-mounts and write state to the wrong disk.
== OSS vendor-neutralization (waves 1+2) ==
- scripts/grpn/ → scripts/ops/. Customer-specific identifiers
(project IDs, internal hostnames, dev/prod VM IPs, brand names)
replaced with placeholders across code, docs, Terraform, Caddyfile,
OAuth probe, and planning docs. Downstream infra repos that copied
scripts/grpn/agnes-tls-rotate.sh or agnes-auto-upgrade.sh must
update the path.
== Translation ==
- src/repositories/user_groups.py::ensure_system docstring translated
from Czech to English for codebase consistency.
Co-authored-by: Mina Rustamyan <mina@keboola.com>
* feat(auth): v9 schema — unified role management foundation (WIP)
Tasks 1-5, 10 of the role-management-complete plan. Foundation only,
follow-up commits add REST API, CLI, UI, and tests.
Schema v9:
- user_role_grants table: direct user → internal_role mapping
(complementary to group_mappings). Drives PAT/headless auth and
persists across sessions. Source field tracks 'direct' vs auto-seed.
- internal_roles.implies (JSON): transitive role hierarchy. core.admin
implies core.km_admin → core.analyst → core.viewer. Resolver does BFS
expand at lookup time.
- internal_roles.is_core (BOOL): distinguishes seeded core.* hierarchy
from module-registered roles. UI renders them differently.
- v8→v9 migration: ADD COLUMN, CREATE TABLE, _seed_core_roles +
_backfill_users_role_to_grants, then NULL legacy users.role values.
DuckDB FK constraint blocks DROP COLUMN — sloupec zůstává jako
deprecated artifact (UserRepository ignoruje), fyzický drop deferred.
Resolver:
- Regex extended to allow dotted namespace (core.admin,
context_engineering.admin), max 64 chars total.
- expand_implies(role_keys, conn): BFS over implies JSON column.
- resolve_internal_roles signature gains optional user_id parameter;
unions group-mapping resolution with user_role_grants direct grants
before implies expansion.
require_internal_role:
- Two-path resolution: session cache (OAuth) → DB grants (PAT/headless
fallback). PAT clients now legitimately satisfy gates without the
OAuth round-trip, fixing the v8 limitation where every PAT-callable
admin endpoint needed require_role(Role.ADMIN) instead of
require_internal_role(...).
Backward-compat:
- require_role(Role.X) and require_admin become thin wrappers over
require_internal_role(f"core.{role}"). Implies hierarchy preserves the
legacy "at least this level" semantics automatically — no per-level
comparison code needed.
- src/rbac.py helpers (is_admin, has_role, get_user_role,
set_user_role, can_access_table, get_accessible_tables) all read from
the resolver via _get_internal_role_keys.
- UserRepository.create() and update() now mirror role changes into
user_role_grants via _grant_core_role helper. Preserves API while
making the new table the source of truth.
- UserRepository.delete() pre-deletes user_role_grants rows
(FK cascade — DuckDB doesn't auto-cascade).
- count_admins() reads user_role_grants ⨝ internal_roles instead of the
now-NULL users.role column.
First consumer:
- app/api/admin.py module-level docstring documents the v9 pattern for
future module authors. Existing require_role(Role.ADMIN) callsites
flow through the wrapper; no behavior change for OAuth callers, and
PAT callers gain access via direct grants.
Tests: full suite green (1396 passed, 6 skipped). Existing tests
exercise the new pathway transparently because UserRepository.create
auto-grants. New test_pat_caller_with_direct_grant_passes pins the
PAT-aware contract.
Schema: v9 (was v8). pyproject.toml + CHANGELOG bump deferred to the
final PR-prep commit.
* feat(auth): role management complete — REST API + CLI + UI + docs (v0.11.4)
Sjednocuje legacy users.role enum s v8 internal-roles foundation pod jeden
model s implies hierarchií, dodává admin UI + REST API + CLI pro správu
group mappings i přímých user grants, a dělá require_internal_role
PAT-aware tak, aby admin endpointy fungovaly uniformly napříč OAuth
i headless callery.
REST API (app/api/role_management.py, +496 LOC):
- 8 endpointů pod /api/admin: internal-roles list, group-mappings CRUD,
users/{id}/role-grants CRUD, users/{id}/effective-roles debug.
- Všechny gated require_internal_role("core.admin"). Audit-log na každé
mutaci (role_mapping.created/deleted, role_grant.created/deleted).
- Last-admin protection: refuse to delete the final core.admin grant
(mirrors users.py:count_admins protection).
- Nový UserRoleGrantsRepository v src/repositories/user_role_grants.py.
CLI (cli/commands/admin.py extension, +258 LOC):
- da admin role list / show <key>
- da admin mapping list / create <group-id> <role-key> / delete <id>
- da admin grant-role <email> <role-key>
- da admin revoke-role <email> <role-key>
- da admin effective-roles <email>
- Všechno přes typer + PAT auth, --json flag, response-shape tolerantní.
UI (admin_role_mapping.html + admin_user_detail.html + nav + user list):
- Nová stránka /admin/role-mapping: internal_roles read-only table +
group_mappings table with create/delete forms.
- Nová stránka /admin/users/{id}: core role single-select + capabilities
multi-checkbox + effective-roles debug (direct + group + expanded).
- Existing user list dostává "Detail" link na novou stránku.
- Nav link na /admin/role-mapping.
Tests: +85 nových testů přes 4 nové soubory:
- test_schema_v9_migration.py (8) — fresh install + v8→v9 backfill +
legacy column NULL semantics + unknown-role fallback + invariants.
- test_api_role_management.py (33) — všech 8 endpointů, happy + error
paths, audit-log assertions, last-admin protection.
- test_cli_admin_role.py (25 + 1 conditional) — typer subcommands,
text + json output, PAT integration smoke.
- test_admin_role_mapping_ui.py (9) + test_admin_user_capabilities_ui.py (10)
— page rendering, auth gating, form contracts, JS hooks.
Full suite: 1482 passed, 6 skipped (was 1396 → +86, žádné regrese).
Docs:
- docs/internal-roles.md kompletní rewrite — odstranil "no UI yet",
přidal hierarchy diagram, dual-path resolution, dotted-namespace
convention, admin workflow přes UI/CLI/REST, refresh semantics
for group mappings vs direct grants, migration notes.
- CLAUDE.md schema v8 → v9.
- CHANGELOG.md [0.11.4] s BREAKING marker pro users.role NULL
semantics + complete Added/Changed/Removed/Internal sekce.
- pyproject.toml: 0.11.3 → 0.11.4.
Sequencing: po mergi tohoto PR Pabu rebasuje pabu/local-dev (PR #72)
na main, jeho schema migrations se posouvají z v9/v10/v11 na v10/v11/v12.
Implementation breakdown:
- Sequential (já): foundation tasks — schema v9, resolver, PAT-aware
require_internal_role, backward-compat wrappers, rbac refactor,
UserRepository auto-grant.
- Parallel sub-agents (3 worktrees, ~10 min): REST API, CLI, UI.
- Sequential (já): integrace, docs/CHANGELOG/version, schema tests,
fullsuite verification.
* fix(auth): address Devin review on PR #73 — three regressions
Three concrete bugs caught in Devin's PR review, all fixed in this commit.
1. **users.role hydration on read** (the big one):
v8→v9 migration NULLs users.role for every existing user, but a long
tail of read sites still inspect user["role"] directly:
- app/web/templates/_app_header.html:15 — admin nav gate
- app/web/templates/_app_header.html:36-37 — role badge in dropdown
- app/web/router.py:319-321 — UserInfo.is_admin/is_analyst/is_privileged
- app/web/router.py:489 — corporate memory is_km_admin
- app/api/catalog.py:54 — admin "see all tables" bypass
- app/api/sync.py:215 — admin "see all sync states" bypass
Without a fix, every existing admin loses the entire admin nav (and
API admin bypasses) immediately after upgrade — a serious regression.
Fix: new helper _hydrate_legacy_role() in app/auth/dependencies.py
maps the highest-level core.* grant back into user["role"] as the
legacy enum string. Called from get_current_user() on both auth paths
(LOCAL_DEV_MODE + JWT/PAT). Idempotent — skips when role is already
populated. Net effect: every pre-v9 callsite keeps working transparently
for both OAuth and PAT callers, with one extra DB round-trip per
authenticated request (same cost as the existing PAT-aware
require_internal_role fallback).
3 regression tests in tests/test_schema_v9_migration.py:
- test_hydration_recovers_role_from_user_role_grants
- test_hydration_returns_highest_grant (multi-grant → highest wins)
- test_hydration_falls_back_to_viewer_when_no_grants (safe fallback)
2. **CLI effective-roles TypeError**:
API returns direct/group as List[Dict] (RoleGrantResponse-shaped),
but the CLI did ', '.join(direct) which raises TypeError on dicts.
Tests masked it because mocks used bare string lists. Replaced
raw .join() with a _names() helper that extracts role_key from
each item, falling back to str() for legacy mock shapes.
3. **UI template field-name mismatch**:
admin_user_detail.html JS reads data.groups but the API serializes
the field as group (singular, per EffectiveRolesResponse pydantic).
Currently benign because the API always returns group:[], but the
field would silently disappear once the group-derived view is wired
up. Added data.group as the primary lookup, kept the legacy aliases
for shape-drift tolerance.
Full suite: 1485 passed (was 1482, +3 hydration tests), 6 skipped, no
regressions.
* fix(auth): Devin review #2 + UX self-service + RBAC docs rename
Three threads landed in one commit because they share the same
auth/role surface and CHANGELOG entry.
Devin review #73 second round (2 actionable findings):
- _hydrate_legacy_role no longer short-circuits on truthy users.role.
The role-management endpoints (POST/DELETE /api/admin/users/{id}/
role-grants + the changeCoreRole UI flow) only mutate
user_role_grants — they don't update the legacy column. The early
return trusted that stale value, so a user downgraded via the new
REST/UI kept role="admin" in their dict on subsequent requests,
which fooled _is_admin_user_dict (src/rbac.py) and the catalog/sync
admin-bypass short-circuits into retaining elevated table access
even though require_internal_role correctly denied the API gates.
Always re-resolves now, making user_role_grants the single source
of truth on every authenticated request. Cost: one DB round-trip
per request — same as the existing PAT-aware fallback. Pinned by
test_hydration_ignores_stale_legacy_role_after_grant_revoke.
- Dev-bypass (app/auth/dependencies.py) and OAuth callback
(app/auth/providers/google.py) now pass user_id to
resolve_internal_roles so direct grants land in
session["internal_roles"] alongside group-mapped roles. Pre-fix,
every admin-gated request fell through to the per-request DB
fallback inside require_internal_role and the dev-bypass log line
read "resolved 0 internal role(s)" for an obviously-admin user.
test_session_internal_roles_populated updated to assert union.
User-visible UX (also addresses local-test feedback):
- HTTP 500 on /admin/users post-v8→v9 migration — UserResponse.role
is required str, but legacy users.role was NULL-ed by the
migration. _to_response in app/api/users.py now routes every dict
through _hydrate_legacy_role; same fix lifts the silent no-op of
last-admin protection in update_user/delete_user (the role-equality
short-circuits would skip the count_admins guard for migrated
admins). Three regression tests under TestAPIUsersPostMigration.
- /profile is now a real self-service detail page for *every*
signed-in user (not just admins). Three new server-side sections:
Effective roles (resolver output as chip cloud), Direct grants
(rows in user_role_grants with source label), Roles via groups
(which Cloud Identity / dev group grants which role for the
current user). Non-admins finally see *why* a feature is or isn't
accessible. Admins additionally see a deep-link to
/admin/users/{id} for editing their own grants.
- /admin/role-mapping group-id picker. New "Known groups" panel
above the create form: clickable chips for the calling admin's
own session.google_groups (tagged "your group") merged with
external_group_ids already used in existing mappings (tagged
"already mapped"). Click a chip → fills the form. Empty-state
copy points operators at LOCAL_DEV_GROUPS / Google sign-in
instead of leaving them to guess Cloud Identity opaque IDs from
memory.
Operational fixes:
- Scheduler log-noise: every cron tick produced a
POST /auth/token 401 because the auto-fetch fallback called the
endpoint with just an email (no password) and silently fell
through. Removed the broken path entirely. Operators set
SCHEDULER_API_TOKEN (long-lived PAT) in production; in
LOCAL_DEV_MODE the dev-bypass auto-authenticates the un-tokenized
request, so jobs continue to work.
Docs:
- docs/internal-roles.md → docs/RBAC.md (git mv preserves history).
Standard industry term, more discoverable for engineers grepping
for RBAC in a new repo. Restructured: Quickstart-by-role
(operator / end-user / module author), step-by-step
Module-author workflow with code examples (register key, gate
endpoint, declare implies, write contract test), naming pitfalls,
refresh semantics. CLAUDE.md gets a new
"Extensibility → RBAC" section pointing contributors at the doc
before they add gated endpoints. Cross-refs in app/api/admin.py
+ tests/test_role_resolver.py updated.
Tests: 293 in the auth/role/scheduler/UI test set passed, 0 regressions.
* fix(auth): Devin review #3 — login flows + RBAC docs
Two new findings on commit 7d1c048, both real and addressed.
Finding 1 (BUG, HTTP 500): every auth login flow loaded users via
UserRepository.get_by_email and passed user["role"] straight to
create_access_token, Pydantic response models, and _set_login_cookie
without going through _hydrate_legacy_role. Post-v9 the legacy column
is NULL for migrated users, and TokenResponse.role is a required str —
so POST /auth/token raised ValidationError → HTTP 500 for any v8-admin
trying to log in via password. Same root cause produced non-crashing
but semantically wrong JWTs (role: null) from Google OAuth, password
web flows, and email magic-link verification.
Fix: hydrate inline in every login flow before reading user["role"]:
- app/auth/router.py — POST /auth/token (the crash site)
- app/auth/providers/google.py — OAuth callback (was just stale JWT)
- app/auth/providers/password.py — 5 flows: JSON login, web login,
JSON setup, web reset confirm, web setup confirm
- app/auth/providers/email.py — centralized in _consume_token,
covers both /verify endpoints
New regression class TestAuthLoginFlowsPostMigration pins both the
no-crash and the correct-role contracts for all four legacy levels
(viewer/analyst/km_admin/admin) on POST /auth/token.
Finding 2 (DOCS): docs/RBAC.md showed register_internal_role() being
called with implies=[...], but the function signature is (key, *,
display_name, description, owner_module). A module author copying the
example would TypeError at import time. The implies field on
internal_roles IS honored at runtime by expand_implies, but the
registry-side write path (register_internal_role + InternalRoleSpec +
sync_registered_roles_to_db) doesn't exist yet — implies is currently
seeded only for the core.* hierarchy via _seed_core_roles in src/db.py.
Rewrote the Implies hierarchy and Module-author workflow sections to
document what's actually supported in 0.11.4 and what a future change
would need to add. The "for cross-module hierarchies, register each
level + grant both" pattern works today.
Tests: 322 in the auth/role/scheduler/UI/password test set passed,
0 regressions.
* fix(db): _seed_core_roles actually runs on every connect (Devin review #4)
Devin flagged that the docstring on `_seed_core_roles` promised per-connect
execution as a safety net for accidental DELETEs and in-code seed changes,
but the only call sites lived inside `if current < SCHEMA_VERSION:` — so
once a DB was on v9 the function never ran again, and the docstring lied.
Picked option (b) from the review (actually call it on every startup) over
option (a) (fix the docstring) because the safety net is genuinely useful:
- recovery from accidental admin DELETE on internal_roles,
- in-code _CORE_ROLES_SEED tweaks (display_name/description/implies)
ship without a manual SQL deploy,
- fresh installs and migrations stop needing their own seed call sites.
Tail call gated by `get_schema_version(conn) <= SCHEMA_VERSION` so the
future-version-is-noop rollback contract still holds — a v9 binary won't
touch a DB that's been upgraded past v9.
Test coverage: new TestSeedCoreRolesSafetyNet class (3 tests) pins the
three contracts — deleted row re-seeds, mutated display_name re-syncs
from in-code seed, applied_at on schema_version doesn't churn on
already-current DBs. Existing TestMigrationSafety::test_future_version_is_noop
still passes (verified against the gating logic).
- KeboolaClient has test_connection() not verify_token() — every
/api/admin/configure call for Keboola was failing with AttributeError
- Renamed data_source.keboola.url → stack_url to match
instance.yaml.example (line 106) and avoid user confusion
663 tests pass.
- CalVer retry loop now exits with error if all 5 attempts fail
(prevents pushing Docker image with unclaimed version tag)
- discover_tables endpoint reads data_source.keboola.url (consistent
with configure_instance and _discover_and_register_tables)
- Pre-migration snapshot flushes WAL via CHECKPOINT before copying
and copies .wal file if it still exists after flush
663 tests pass.
- _discover_and_register_tables reads from data_source.keboola.url
(matches what /api/admin/configure writes) instead of top-level
keboola.url which doesn't exist
- CalVer: claim git tag BEFORE Docker build with retry loop (up to 5
attempts). Prevents race where two concurrent CI runs get same N.
Git tag acts as a distributed lock for version uniqueness.
663 tests pass.
- Config writes to DATA_DIR/state/instance.yaml (writable) instead of
CONFIG_DIR (read-only :ro in Docker)
- instance_config.py checks DATA_DIR/state/ first, then falls back to
CONFIG_DIR for backward compat
- CalVer counter is now global across channels (*-YYYY.MM.*) per spec
- Keboola error messages sanitized — log full error, return generic msg
- chmod in secrets.py wrapped in try/except for Windows compat
- Setup wizard JS handles 401 (expired JWT) with user-facing message
- deploy.yml changed to workflow_dispatch only (no duplicate test runs)
- Smoke test uses docker-compose.prod.yml + AGNES_TAG instead of sed
- docker-compose.prod.yml uses ${AGNES_TAG:-stable} env var
663 tests pass. 8 E2E verification tests pass.
