agnes-the-ai-analyst/tests/test_store_guardrails_reaper.py
Vojtech d6ad08f107
Flea-market upload guardrails + soft delete + JOIN-based admin queue (#233)
* feat(store): flea-market upload guardrails + soft delete + JOIN-based admin queue

Adds an end-to-end guardrails pipeline for store uploads (manifest +
static-security + LLM review), persists blocked bundles for forensics,
introduces soft-delete (Archive) semantics, consolidates the legacy
/store/{id} surface into /marketplace/flea/{id}, and reworks the admin
queue so lifecycle filters read live entity visibility via LEFT JOIN
rather than a denormalized submission column.

Schema v29 → v35:
  * v29 store_submissions table + store_entities.visibility_status
  * v30 file_size, bundle_sha256, bundle_purged_at on submissions
  * v31 reshape store_submissions (drop legacy unique on entity_id)
  * v32 store_entities.archived_at/by + 'archived' visibility value
  * v33 drop store_submissions.retry_count (unused)
  * v34 ensure idx_store_submissions_entity exists post column-drop
  * v35 broaden visibility_status enum + JOIN architecture cutover

Pipeline (src/store_guardrails/):
  * Inline checks: manifest_check, static_scan, quality_check
  * LLM review configurable haiku|sonnet|opus (default haiku)
  * BackgroundTasks-driven async path with structured-output JSON
  * Per-submitter daily quota (default 50)
  * 30-day TTL purge job (POST /api/admin/run-blocked-purge)
  * Bundle SHA256 + size persisted; sha256 survives purge for forensics

Visibility model:
  * pending | approved | hidden | archived
  * _enforce_visibility returns 404 (no leak) for non-owner non-admin
  * Owner sees own non-approved entries via include_owner_id widening
  * Install refused with 409 entity_not_approved when not approved

Soft-delete (DELETE /api/store/entities/{id}):
  * Default = soft (visibility_status='archived'); existing installs
    keep getting served the bundle so users don't lose the plugin
  * ?hard=true admin-only: drops bundle + cascades user_store_installs
  * Hard-delete preserves entity_id on submission as tombstone so
    audit_log linkage survives for the activity timeline

Admin queue lifecycle (the JOIN refactor):
  * Verdict (store_submissions.status) is immutable forensic record
  * Lifecycle (store_entities.visibility_status) is live state
  * /admin/store/submissions Archived chip translates to
    `e.visibility_status='archived'` via LEFT JOIN — any path that
    flips visibility surfaces in the queue immediately
  * Detail page renders Status (verdict) and Entity lifecycle side by
    side so admins see "approved at review, now archived" at a glance

URL consolidation:
  * /store/{id} deleted (no redirect, stale bookmarks 404)
  * /marketplace/flea/{id} is the canonical detail surface
  * Three in-tree callers (upload-success, my-stack card, store
    listing card) updated to point at the new URL
  * Quarantine banner extracted to _quarantine_banner.html partial,
    self-guarded, included from both flea detail templates
  * Banner JS auto-refreshes when the verdict lands by polling
    /api/marketplace/flea/{id}/detail (visibility_status +
    submission_status — the latter is needed because blocked_llm
    keeps the entity at visibility_status='pending')

Audit log resource format:
  * runner.py emits prefixed `store_submission:{id}` (post-fix)
  * Detail-page timeline query handles three patterns: prefixed
    submission, helper-emitted `store_entity:{sub_id}`, and bare-id
    legacy rows — all surface in the activity timeline

UX fixes:
  * Owner sees Under review / Quarantined / Hidden banner with status
  * Install button gray-disabled (not blue) when non-approved
  * Owner cannot delete quarantined entries (403); admin can
  * Admin queue: filter chips, sortable columns, paging, page-size
  * Auto-refresh queue every 5s while pending rows are visible
  * Store upload page file picker no longer opens twice (label →
    input default action collided with explicit JS handler)

Tests: 168 passed across the guardrails suites (admin submissions,
store API, inline / LLM / purge guardrails, store repositories,
marketplace filter, schema version). New regression coverage
includes: archive surfaces via JOIN even when API path is bypassed;
deleted submission renders activity timeline (tombstone); flea
detail surfaces submission_status only for owner/admin; detail page
renders Entity lifecycle row; audit log resource format covers both
helper and runner paths.

* fix(store-guardrails): PR #233 follow-up — prompt injection, atomic PUT, BG race, schema, reaper, sort whitelist

Addresses 9 of the 23 findings from the PR #233 review (spec at
docs/superpowers/specs/2026-05-09-pr233-guardrails-fixes-spec.md).
Merge-gate items #1-#6 plus high-value mediums #7, #9-#12, #23.
Architectural items (#8 enum split, #14 factory) and pure
maintainability (#15-#22) deferred to follow-ups.

Security:
* #1 prompt injection — SYSTEM_PROMPT now passed via the SDK's
  dedicated system= parameter; bundle wrapped in <bundle>...</bundle>
  sentinels declared data-only by the system prompt; literal
  sentinel strings in user content are escaped so an adversarial
  README can't forge a close tag.
* #6 static scan honesty — module docstring + admin copy + docs
  declare static scan as signal not gate; .md/.txt/.rst/.html/.json/
  .yaml/.yml/.toml skipped to avoid false positives on prose.
  AST mode for Python deferred (separate flag, FP comparison work).

Correctness:
* #2 PUT atomicity — bundles bake into plugin.staging-<rand>/
  alongside live, atomic-rename on success; failed checks leave
  live tree byte-for-byte intact.
* #3 BG-task race — set_visibility_if_pending guards verdict flips
  to the (pending, hidden) review window; admin archives during
  review survive; skipped flips audit-logged.
* #4 v35 NOT NULL/DEFAULT — schema v35→v36 re-applies them on
  store_entities.visibility_status. CHECK constraint enforced
  application-side (DuckDB ADD CHECK on existing column unsupported).
* #7 stuck-review reaper — reap_stuck_llm_reviews flips pending_llm
  rows older than guardrails.stuck_review_grace_seconds (default
  1800) to review_error. Scheduler runs every 15 min via new
  /api/admin/run-reap-stuck-reviews. Set knob to 0 to disable.
* #9 quota counter — count_blocked_for_submitter_since now counts
  blocked_inline + blocked_llm + review_error so a submitter
  triggering only LLM-blocked verdicts is bounded.
* #10 missing risk_level — surfaces as review_error with
  error='missing_risk_level' instead of silently defaulting to
  'medium' (which looked like a model-decided block).
* #11 archived_at clear — set_visibility nulls archived_at +
  archived_by when transitioning out of 'archived' so a future
  read doesn't show stale archive forensics on an approved row.

Maintainability:
* #12 FSM doc comment — accurate insert/transition/lifecycle
  description in src/db.py near store_submissions schema.
* #23 sort-key whitelist — admin queue rejects unknown sort keys
  with 400 invalid_sort_key; substring-replace footgun removed.

Deferred (separate PRs):
* #5 quota race — proper fix requires asyncio.Lock spanning the
  full pipeline; threading.Lock blocks event loop, DuckDB MVCC
  doesn't help. API-level slowapi bounds worst case for now.
* #6 part 3 (AST static scan), #8 (enum split), #13 (import
  bundle docs), #14 (factory consolidation), #15-#22 (maint).

Tests:
* New: tests/test_store_guardrails_prompt_injection.py (corpus +
  trust-boundary invariants), tests/test_store_put_atomic.py,
  tests/test_store_guardrails_reaper.py.
* Extended: test_store_guardrails_llm.py (system param, missing
  risk_level, BG race), test_admin_store_submissions.py (quota
  counter widening, sort whitelist 400), test_store_repositories.py
  (un-archive metadata clear), test_db_schema_version.py (v36).
* Full suite: 3738 passed; 17 pre-existing baseline failures
  unchanged (db migration tests, cli binary rename, catalog export,
  user mgmt v5 backfill — confirmed by stash + rerun on clean tree).
2026-05-09 17:32:53 +04:00

139 lines
5.3 KiB
Python

"""Stuck-review reaper (#7 from PR #233 review).
A submission stuck at ``status='pending_llm'`` past the configured
grace gets flipped to ``review_error`` so admin can retry. Sweeps
every 15 min via scheduler.
Tests:
* row older than grace → flipped + audit written
* row younger than grace → untouched
* no pending_llm rows → no-op
* grace_seconds=0 → reaper short-circuits
* idempotent: running twice doesn't double-flip
"""
from __future__ import annotations
import json
from datetime import datetime, timedelta, timezone
import pytest
from src import db as src_db
from src.repositories.store_entities import StoreEntitiesRepository
from src.repositories.store_submissions import StoreSubmissionsRepository
from src.repositories.users import UserRepository
from src.store_guardrails.reaper import reap_stuck_llm_reviews
@pytest.fixture
def conn(tmp_path, monkeypatch):
monkeypatch.setenv("DATA_DIR", str(tmp_path))
src_db._system_db_conn = None
src_db._system_db_path = None
c = src_db.get_system_db()
yield c
c.close()
def _seed_pending(conn, name: str, age_seconds: int) -> str:
"""Stage a pending_llm submission whose created_at is `age_seconds`
in the past. Returns the submission id."""
UserRepository(conn).create(
id=f"u-{name}", email=f"{name}@x.com", name=name,
)
StoreEntitiesRepository(conn).create(
id=f"e-{name}", owner_user_id=f"u-{name}", owner_username=name,
type="skill", name=name, description="x", category=None,
version="1.0.0", file_size=10, visibility_status="pending",
)
sub_id = StoreSubmissionsRepository(conn).create(
submitter_id=f"u-{name}", submitter_email=f"{name}@x.com",
type="skill", name=name, version="1.0.0",
status="pending_llm", entity_id=f"e-{name}",
inline_checks={"manifest": {"status": "pass"}},
)
# Backdate created_at — repo timestamps with NOW(), so we override.
backdated = datetime.now(timezone.utc) - timedelta(seconds=age_seconds)
conn.execute(
"UPDATE store_submissions SET created_at = ? WHERE id = ?",
[backdated, sub_id],
)
return sub_id
class TestReaper:
def test_reaps_old_pending_llm(self, conn):
sub_id = _seed_pending(conn, "old-stuck", age_seconds=3600)
result = reap_stuck_llm_reviews(conn, grace_seconds=1800)
assert result["reaped"] == 1
sub = StoreSubmissionsRepository(conn).get(sub_id)
assert sub["status"] == "review_error"
assert (sub["llm_findings"] or {}).get("error") == "timeout_or_crash"
audits = conn.execute(
"SELECT params FROM audit_log "
"WHERE resource = ? AND action = 'store.submission.review_error'",
[f"store_submission:{sub_id}"],
).fetchall()
assert audits, "missing reaper audit row"
def test_skips_recent_pending_llm(self, conn):
sub_id = _seed_pending(conn, "fresh", age_seconds=60) # 1 min old
result = reap_stuck_llm_reviews(conn, grace_seconds=1800)
assert result["reaped"] == 0
sub = StoreSubmissionsRepository(conn).get(sub_id)
assert sub["status"] == "pending_llm"
def test_grace_zero_short_circuits(self, conn):
sub_id = _seed_pending(conn, "old-but-disabled", age_seconds=10000)
result = reap_stuck_llm_reviews(conn, grace_seconds=0)
assert result["skipped"] is True
sub = StoreSubmissionsRepository(conn).get(sub_id)
assert sub["status"] == "pending_llm"
def test_idempotent(self, conn):
sub_id = _seed_pending(conn, "twice", age_seconds=3600)
first = reap_stuck_llm_reviews(conn, grace_seconds=1800)
second = reap_stuck_llm_reviews(conn, grace_seconds=1800)
assert first["reaped"] == 1
assert second["reaped"] == 0
sub = StoreSubmissionsRepository(conn).get(sub_id)
assert sub["status"] == "review_error"
def test_no_pending_rows_is_noop(self, conn):
result = reap_stuck_llm_reviews(conn, grace_seconds=1800)
assert result["reaped"] == 0
assert result["skipped"] is False
def test_does_not_flip_other_statuses(self, conn):
"""Approved / blocked / overridden rows older than grace must
not be touched — the reaper is scoped to pending_llm only."""
UserRepository(conn).create(id="u1", email="u1@x.com", name="u1")
StoreEntitiesRepository(conn).create(
id="e1", owner_user_id="u1", owner_username="u1",
type="skill", name="approved-old", description="x",
category=None, version="1.0.0", file_size=10,
visibility_status="approved",
)
sub_id = StoreSubmissionsRepository(conn).create(
submitter_id="u1", submitter_email="u1@x.com",
type="skill", name="approved-old", version="1.0.0",
status="approved", entity_id="e1",
inline_checks={"manifest": {"status": "pass"}},
)
backdated = datetime.now(timezone.utc) - timedelta(hours=24)
conn.execute(
"UPDATE store_submissions SET created_at = ? WHERE id = ?",
[backdated, sub_id],
)
result = reap_stuck_llm_reviews(conn, grace_seconds=1800)
assert result["reaped"] == 0
sub = StoreSubmissionsRepository(conn).get(sub_id)
assert sub["status"] == "approved"